Skip to content

DHCR's 9% round vs. HFA's 4% bond process — New York

Phase 4 of 11
Browse other state and territory guides

"Do we compete for a scarce 9% ceiling allocation, or take HFA's as-of-right 4% bond credit — and can this deal do both?"

Scenario modelingDevelopment timing: Weeks to model both paths against the deal; DHCR's own bond-eligibility finding runs 60 days once a complete application is filed, and the 9% program runs one competitive RFP round a year
Put the guide to work

How EZFeasi helps at this stage

Use scenarios and the Unit Mixer to explore unit counts, affordability and financing alternatives. Put those results beside published applications and awards as you shape your competition strategy.

Two agencies, and more than one rulebook for the 4% side

DHCR's competitive 9% process is set out in full at 9 NYCRR Part 2040. Bond-financed 4% credits are, per §2040.4(a), "processed by the New York State Housing Finance Agency under its procedures" — which in practice means HFA's own regulation, Part 2188 (a separate Title 9 part, issued under authority granted by Part 2040). Part 2188 itself says that projects drawing on the competitive State Credit Ceiling — as opposed to as-of-right, volume-cap 4% credits — fall back under Part 2040's allocation process instead. So which rulebook actually governs a given 4% deal depends on how it's structured, not just on the '4%' label.

Part 2040 also keeps its own bond-application provision at §2040.4(b)–(d), for applications filed directly with DHCR. Under it, DHCR reviews the application against the same threshold-eligibility criteria (§2040.3(e)) and scoring criteria (§2040.3(f)) the 9% round uses — but only "for eligibility and public purpose," within 60 days of a complete filing. Critically, the credit amount is not set by DHCR's competitive ranking rule (§2040.3(g)(1)(ii), which operates "among the projects selected for a credit allocation" in a competitive round) — it's set under §2040.4(d), where "the issuer of the tax exempt bonds is responsible for determining the dollar amount of credit which is necessary for the financial feasibility of the project." A 4% deal borrows DHCR's threshold and scoring language for public-purpose review, but skips its competitive dollar-ranking entirely.

$3,000, due at submission9% application fee
$2,000, due at submission4% (DHCR-filed bond) application fee
8% of first-year credit, due at carryover allocation9% credit allocation fee
3% of first-year allocation, due at final allocation4% credit allocation fee

9% also charges a separate $1,000 fee if a binding agreement is requested, and lets Non-profit, MBE, WBE, or Certified SDVOB applicants (as sole general partner or managing member) defer processing fees to carryover. The DHCR-filed bond path's deferral is narrower on paper: §2040.4(c) allows only not-for-profit applicants to defer, and only the application fee itself — not a broader "processing fees" deferral. Don't assume the 9% side's MBE/WBE/SDVOB deferral carries over to a bond filing; the text doesn't say it does.

The other side of the trade-off is credit size. 9% still delivers roughly nine times the annual credit rate of the federal 4% floor established by the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 (IRC §42(b)(3)) — meaning a 4% deal raises far less tax-credit equity per dollar of qualified basis, and structurally depends on subordinate subsidy (HFA, and in NYC, HPD/HDC second mortgages) to close the resulting gap.

New York City: HPD/HDC layer on top of, not instead of, HFA

HDC's ELLA program (targeting units affordable primarily below 60% AMI) and its New Construction program (targeting primarily below 80% AMI) are both bond-financed 4% structures, each pairing tax-exempt bond proceeds with a subordinate HDC second mortgage of up to $65,000/unit — capped at $15 million per project under ELLA, $20 million under New Construction. Both underwrite to the same 1.15 minimum DSCR and 1.05 minimum income-to-expense ratio HFA uses statewide — confirmed independently in HFA's own Winter 2026 term sheet and in HPD's July 2025 New Construction Finance term sheet. A NYC bond deal isn't a separate underwriting universe; it's the same floor with HPD added as a second, parallel funder.

HPD's own per-unit subsidy ceiling (its July 2025 New Construction Finance term sheet, Table 2) runs roughly $160,000–$420,000 per unit depending on the project's LIHTC percentage/Target Average AMI tier and whether it's 4% or 9% financed — set as a maximum, not a guarantee; HPD explicitly expects sponsors to seek competitive pricing and additional sources first.

NYC deals also carry a property-tax-benefit menu that doesn't exist upstate: §421-a, §485-x, §420-c, and Article XI exemptions, layered on top of the LIHTC structure. §420-c(4) is the one written for tax-credit housing, and it tests the owner and the regulatory agreement rather than a share of units: the property must be or have been in the federal tax credit program, the owner must be an entity at least 50% of whose controlling interest is held by a charitable organization (§420-c(4)(a)(5)), and the exemption from local real property taxation applies "except as may be otherwise provided in such regulatory agreement" (§420-c(4)(b)), which can require payments in lieu of taxes — a real, checkable test, not a formality. Outside the city, the equivalent relief usually comes from a local IDA PILOT agreement instead, a different mechanism entirely.

What the election actually turns on

9% buys more credit per unit of basis but comes with DHCR's full competitive scoring exposure, a single annual RFP round, and — per phase 6 — a real Cost Effectiveness ceiling on how expensive the construction package can be. A DHCR-filed or HFA-processed 4% deal is as-of-right once bond volume cap is secured, skips DHCR's competitive credit-dollar ranking, and moves on a rolling basis rather than an annual calendar — a real advantage for a site with a fixed construction-start deadline that doesn't line up with the 9% round.

Combining a 9% competitive phase with a 4% bond-financed phase on the same site ("twinning") is a nationally standard structuring technique, and HFA's own program materials note that DHCR can designate 9% ceiling credit to projects not subject to tax-exempt bond financing. That said, the precise New York-specific mechanics of twinning two phases together are not confirmed against primary regulatory text — treat it as a generic structuring option to verify against current HCR RFP guidance and counsel before relying on it, not as a codified NY program with defined rules.

Checks before you move forward

  • Assuming Part 2188 and DHCR's §2040.4 are the same process — they're related (2188 was issued under Part 2040's authority) but distinct, and mixing up which one's fee schedule or deadline applies produces the wrong check amount at submission.
  • Assuming the 9% side's MBE/WBE/SDVOB fee-deferral eligibility carries over to a DHCR-filed bond application — §2040.4(c)'s text names only not-for-profit applicants.
  • Filing a bond application assuming DHCR's competitive credit-ranking rule (§2040.3(g)(1)(ii)) caps the award — under §2040.4(d), the bond issuer's own feasibility determination governs instead.
  • Treating HPD's Table 2 per-unit subsidy figures as guaranteed rather than maximums — HPD explicitly expects sponsors to contain costs and seek other sources before hitting the term-sheet ceiling.
  • Assuming NYC's DSCR/income-expense underwriting diverges from the statewide HFA standard — HPD's own July 2025 term sheet mirrors HFA's 1.15 DSCR / 1.05 income-expense floor almost exactly.
  • Electing §420-c property tax relief without confirming the owner meets its test — an entity at least 50% of whose controlling interest is held by a charitable organization (§420-c(4)(a)(5)) — and without reading the regulatory agreement, which can require payments in lieu of taxes (§420-c(4)(b)).
  • Underestimating how much slower the 9% path is relative to the rolling bond path — a single annual competitive round can structurally mismatch a site with a hard construction-start deadline.
  • Treating "twinning" 9% and 4% phases as a defined, codified NY program — it's a generic structuring technique to confirm against current HCR guidance, not a rule with published mechanics.

At a glance

9% fees
$3,000 application fee (submission); $1,000 if a binding agreement is requested; 8% credit allocation fee on first-year credit, due at carryover allocation
4% (DHCR-filed bond) fees
$2,000 application fee (submission); 3% credit allocation fee on first-year allocation, due at final allocation
DHCR bond review windows
60 days from a complete application for the eligibility/public-purpose finding (§2040.4(b)); a further 60 days for final allocation processing (§2040.4(d))
HDC subordinate loan caps
Up to $65,000/unit; $15M project cap under ELLA, $20M under New Construction
HPD per-unit subsidy range
Roughly $160,000–$420,000/unit depending on LIHTC share, Target Average AMI tier, and 4% vs. 9% financing (July 2025 NCF term sheet, Table 2)
§420-c owner test
An entity at least 50% of whose controlling interest is held by a charitable organization (§420-c(4)(a)(5))
Shared underwriting floor
1.15 minimum DSCR, 1.05 minimum income-to-expense ratio — used by both HFA statewide and HPD/HDC in NYC

Governing authority

  • DHCR bond-financed project eligibility, review, and credit-amount rules9 NYCRR § 2040.4
  • DHCR threshold eligibility and scoring criteria cross-referenced by bond applications9 NYCRR § 2040.3(e), (f)
  • DHCR competitive credit-dollar-amount preference (inapplicable to bond-issuer-determined 4% awards)9 NYCRR § 2040.3(g)(1)(ii)
  • 9% DHCR application, binding-agreement, and credit-allocation fees9 NYCRR § 2040.3(c)
  • HFA's own 4% LIHTC allocation regulation, issued under DHCR's Part 2040 authority9 NYCRR Part 2188
  • HDC ELLA and New Construction subordinate-loan termsNYC Housing Development Corporation ELLA and New Construction Term Sheets
  • HPD per-unit subsidy ceilings by affordability tierHPD New Construction Finance Term Sheet (July 2025), Table 2
  • NYC §420-c property tax exemption owner test and regulatory-agreement termsN.Y. Real Property Tax Law § 420-c; HPD Tax Credits and Incentives guidelines

Put the next step to work

Bring your project question to a walkthrough of the relevant EZFeasi tools, with your state and program in view.