Skip to content

Application assembly and submission — New York

Phase 8 of 11
Browse other state and territory guides

"Is this a DHCR 9% competitive submission or an HFA/HDC bond deal — because the portal, the exhibits, and the fee schedule are entirely different?"

Application preparationDevelopment timing: For the 9% track: weeks of exhibit assembly culminating in one hard annual deadline (the 2025 round ran from a July 17 release to an 11:59 PM ET deadline on September 11); for the bond-financed 4% track: no fixed round at all — a rolling pre-application concept paper, filed at least 60 days before the proposed construction start
Put the guide to work

How EZFeasi helps at this stage

Build and review the Proforma, then use it as the financial reference while completing your state’s application template.

DHCR's 9% round: one Aspera dropbox, nine tabs, and a hard annual deadline

Applications aren't submitted through a web portal — they go into an Internet dropbox HCR sets up per project, built on Aspera's file-transfer platform. A sponsor emails MSR@hcr.ny.gov before the access deadline with the project name, county/municipality, and up to two user emails; each user then gets a one-time 'Dropbox Invitation' link from NYS mySend that functions as that user's ID and password. A new dropbox is required for every project, every round — a dropbox used in a prior submission cannot be reused. In the 2025 round, dropbox access had to be requested by August 28 at 3:00 PM ET, with the complete application due September 11 at 11:59 PM ET; HCR explicitly warns that staff won't provide technical support after 4:00 PM on deadline day, despite the 11:59 PM cutoff.

2025 9% RFP application structure
TabContentsExhibits
AApplication & Development TeamA-1 – A-5
BProject/Site InformationB-1 – B-7
CCommunity Needs/Market InformationC-1 – C-2
DDesign & Construction DocumentsD-1 – D-7
EEnvironmental DocumentsE-1 – E-6
FFinancial AnalysisF-1 – F-5
GPreservation DocumentsG-1 – G-9
HLIHTC/SLIHCH-1 – H-2
IConsents and CertificationsI-1 – I-5

Threshold review gates the whole application before scoring even happens: a Technical Assistance session with HCR staff must have occurred within 12 months of submission; site control must remain valid through the later of the construction-finance closing date or six months beyond the application deadline; private lender letters of interest can't be dated more than 45 days before submission, and for 9% LIHTC/SLIHC requests, the equity investor or syndicator letter carries the same 45-day freshness requirement. HCR also enforces a Single Financing Plan rule — an applicant may present only one consistent plan of financing to all funding agencies; submitting multiple financing scenarios makes the application ineligible outright, not just weaker.

Fees, and the binding agreement gate that comes after the initial submission

The 9% LIHTC and/or SLIHC application fee is $3,000 per credit program requested at submission — $6,000 for a sponsor requesting both. Payment is made by check to 'NYS DHCR,' mailed via USPS overnight with a Credit Fee Transmittal Letter to a JPMorgan Chase lockbox address in Brooklyn (HCR does not accept payment at any other office). A not-for-profit applicant (or its wholly-owned subsidiary) or a NYS-certified M/WBE or SDVOB applicant — in each case serving as sole general partner or sole managing member, and not having received an HCR capital award since 2021 — may request deferral of that fee to the time of carryover allocation, but the request has to be filed before the RFP's own deferral deadline, not decided later.

A separate $1,000 fee applies only if and when a binding agreement or similar document is requested — a later-stage step that comes after HCR issues a credit reservation, once the applicant has obtained commitments for all sources of construction and permanent financing and all necessary local approvals. The credit allocation fee itself — 8% of the first-year credit allocation for the 9% program — isn't due at application at all; it's due when the applicant requests issuance of the carryover allocation, well after the award.

HFA's (and, in NYC, HDC's) 4% bond track skips the RFP entirely

Once a project is financed by tax-exempt private activity bonds, it leaves DHCR's competitive process altogether: since March 1, 2008, bond-financed applications are processed by the New York State Housing Finance Agency under HFA's own procedures, not the annual 9% RFP cycle. The published entry point is a pre-application concept paper submitted to the applicable regional Development Director, followed by the HFA Financing Application, the HFA Underwriting Application, a Site Suitability Worksheet, and — where applicable — Historic Preservation Certification. There's no fixed round: a project applies when it's ready, not against a once-a-year deadline.

The regulatory fee schedule for this track — a $2,000 application fee (deferrable for a qualifying not-for-profit sole general partner or managing member) and a 3% credit allocation fee on the first-year allocation, due at final allocation — sits in the same QAP section that governs bond-financed applications, though that section's older submission-timing language (filing 60 days before a proposed construction start, with a 60-day DHCR findings turnaround) reads as carried over from DHCR's pre-2008 direct-processing role; HFA's own current published procedures don't restate a specific turnaround time, so confirm current timing directly with the regional Development Director rather than assuming the QAP's legacy figure still governs. For New York City sites specifically, the same 4% credits can instead be paired with tax-exempt bonds issued by HDC rather than HFA — HDC runs its own underwriting and fee process outside 9 NYCRR entirely, so a NYC sponsor has to know at the outset which of the two bond issuers the deal is actually going through, since the two tracks don't share an application, a fee schedule, or a timeline.

Checks before you move forward

  • Reusing a prior round's Aspera dropbox link — HCR requires a brand-new dropbox request for every project, every round.
  • Submitting on a prior year's application forms — the RFP disqualifies applications on outdated or incorrect forms without further review.
  • Dating the private-lender or equity-investor/syndicator letter of interest more than 45 days before submission — a stale-dated LOI fails threshold review.
  • Filing multiple financing scenarios 'to keep options open' — the Single Financing Plan rule makes this an automatic ineligibility, not a flagged weakness.
  • Assuming the application fee deferral is available on general hardship grounds — it's limited to nonprofit/M/WBE/WBE/SDVOB applicants serving as sole GP or managing member who haven't received an HCR capital award since 2021.
  • Treating the bond-financed 4% track as running on the same annual deadline as the 9% RFP — it's a rolling, concept-paper-first process with its own fee schedule.
  • Skipping the mandatory pre-application Technical Assistance session — threshold review requires it to have occurred within 12 months of submission.
  • For a NYC site, assuming HFA's bond process and HDC's bond process are interchangeable — they're separate issuers with separate underwriting, fees, and applications.

At a glance

9% LIHTC/SLIHC application fee
$3,000 per credit program; $6,000 if requesting both
Binding agreement fee
$1,000, only if/when requested
9% credit allocation fee
8% of first-year credit allocation, due at carryover allocation request
Bond-financed (4%) application fee
$2,000; 3% credit allocation fee due at final allocation
2025 round submission deadline
September 11, 2025, 11:59 PM ET (illustrative of the annual cycle's compressed final month)
Application exhibit structure
9 tabs (A–I), 34 numbered exhibits (A-1 through I-5)
Threshold site-control requirement
Valid through the later of construction-finance closing or 6 months beyond the application deadline
Financing letter freshness requirement
Dated no earlier than 45 days before submission

Governing authority

  • Application fee, transmittal, and deferral rules9 NYCRR § 2040.3(c); 2025 HCR Multifamily Finance 9% LIHTC RFP, Section II ("Application Fees")
  • Aspera dropbox submission mechanics and 2025 deadlines2025 HCR Multifamily Finance 9% LIHTC RFP, Section II ("RFP Timeline and Submission Instructions")
  • Tab/exhibit structure and threshold requirements2025 HCR Multifamily Finance 9% LIHTC RFP, Sections II–III
  • Bond-financed application fee, credit allocation fee, and post-2008 HFA processing9 NYCRR § 2040.4
  • Pre-application concept paper and HFA application sequenceHCR Multifamily Finance – Tax-Exempt Bond and Subsidy Financing Programs (hcr.ny.gov)
  • SLIHC as a parallel, jointly-requestable state credit9 NYCRR § 2040.14 (SLIHC Regulation, effective 6/11/2025)

Put the next step to work

Bring your project question to a walkthrough of the relevant EZFeasi tools, with your state and program in view.